The York Galleria opened in 1989, and at its peak it had four department stores: Sears, JCPenney, Boscov's and the Bon-Ton. This holiday season it has one, Boscov's. Springettsbury Township's comprehensive plan, adopted in July 2025, still calls the Galleria York County's largest shopping mall. The same plan says it has "just one department store."
Each of the other three spaces has new tenants, and none of them is a department store. If you're heading to Whiteford Road for gifts this week, the mall you'll walk into works differently from the one most of us remember. The shopping is concentrated in two places, and much of the rest of the building is now for entertainment, storage and services.
The Boscov's Corner Is the Only Original Anchor Still Selling
Boscov's is the one name left from the mall's original four. The mall's owner, CBL Properties, still lists it among the Galleria's featured stores on its York Galleria property page.
That corner of the mall also pulls in more than shopping. The Family Fun Center, a token-and-ticket arcade, is on the second floor between Boscov's and the food court. If you have kids along and a gift list in hand, those two are the same stretch of mall. The food court itself is on the mall's dining list: Bamboo Express, Sam & Jo Gyros, Taqueria El Chile Toreado, Frey Daddy's Pizza and Auntie Anne's, along with sit-down options like Red Robin and Tokyo II.
JCPenney Was the First to Go, and It Became Three Tenants
JCPenney closed its Galleria store in April 2015, the first anchor to leave. The space never went to a single replacement. Between 2016 and 2018 it was split among H&M, Marshalls and Gold's Gym, and the township plan now counts those as the mall's anchors.
Gold's opened in July 2017 and held its grand opening ribbon-cutting on October 14 of that year, according to the York Daily Record. The gym in the mall's directory today is PA Fitness, and CBL lists H&M, Marshalls and PA Fitness as featured tenants.
For a holiday shopper, the old JCPenney wing is the mall's second retail cluster. Marshalls is the closest thing the Galleria has to a second department store, and H&M covers clothing at a lower price point than Boscov's. The rest of the directory fills in from there. It includes American Eagle, Champs Sports, Foot Locker, JD Sports, Journeys, Hot Topic, Spencer's, Maurices, Bath & Body Works, Kay Jewelers, Joseph Jacob Jewelers, Perfume Palace and the seasonal Go! Calendars & Games.
Sears Became Hollywood Casino York
Sears and the Bon-Ton both closed in 2018. ABC27 reported in April 2018 that the Sears store would close in early August.
Penn National Gaming had wanted a casino at the Galleria since 2018. Springettsbury Township approved its redevelopment plans in 2019, and the state Gaming Control Board licensed the casino later that year. Hollywood Casino York opened at noon on August 12, 2021, on the lower level of the former Sears.
At opening, Penn National's announcement listed about 500 slot machines and 24 table games. It said the space could hold up to 750 slots and 40 tables. CBL's current listing gives the same 500 slots and 24 live table games, now with an ESPN Bet sportsbook, a casual restaurant and bar, and a grab-and-go eatery. The extra capacity planned in 2021 is still there to be built.
For a mall visit, this matters in a practical way. One of the four big corners of the building is now an adults-only gaming floor. If you're bringing kids to see Santa, the Boscov's and food court end of the mall is the side built for them.
The Bon-Ton Became Storage Units
The Bon-Ton space took the longest to fill and changed the most. The township approved a self-storage facility there in early 2020, and Extra Space Storage opened in the former Bon-Ton in May 2022.
It shows up in the mall directory next to Champs Sports and Foot Locker. If you're downsizing, renovating or just need somewhere to keep a crib and a dining table until spring, you can now rent a unit in the same building where you buy shoes.
The Parking Lot Is Next
The Bon-Ton side is also where the Galleria's next change is set to happen. On May 14, 2026, Springettsbury supervisors approved plans for Signature Flats at Galleria. It's a four-story, 98-unit apartment building on a 2.51-acre lot carved from the Extra Space Storage parcel, with bicycle parking, a patio, a dog park and recreation space. The approval minutes describe building on underused parking, not tearing down any part of the mall.
The land changed hands this fall. The York Daily Record reported that the roughly three-acre parcel sold for $1,125,000 in a deal that closed September 29, 2026. PennLive identified the buyer as WMG York LLC, owner of Life Storage, which owns the Extra Space Storage business on the old Bon-Ton site.
The township's 2025 comprehensive plan treats this as part of a larger pattern. It points to shoppers moving online while still seeking in-person dining and entertainment, and it names the Galleria site for residential and mixed-use redevelopment. Those three replaced department stores, a casino, a gym and a storage facility, follow that pattern. So does the apartment building.
Santa's Workshop Is on Level 2
The mall still runs a full holiday season. Santa's Workshop is a seasonal photo space on Level 2, and reservations are taken online through VIP Holiday Photos. The 2026 season runs November 21 through December 24, with packages starting at $35.
The posted hours change as Christmas gets closer:
- November 21 to December 10: noon to 7 p.m. Monday through Saturday, noon to 5 p.m. Sunday.
- December 11 to December 17: 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. Monday through Saturday, noon to 5 p.m. Sunday.
- December 18 to December 24: hours vary, so check the booking calendar.
Pets get their own nights. The mall's Pet Photos with Santa runs Mondays from November 23 through December 14. That's four Mondays, starting November 23. The mall's homepage is also running a six-week "Santa's $3,000 Stocking Giveaway" in gift cards.
Check that homepage for Black Friday and weekend hours before you go. The mall sets holiday store hours separately from the Santa schedule above.
Planning a Galleria Trip Around the New Layout
Most of the holiday shopping happens in two places: Boscov's at one end, and H&M and Marshalls in the old JCPenney space. The Family Fun Center and the food court sit between Boscov's and the middle of the mall. Santa is upstairs on Level 2. The casino, the storage facility and the fitness club fill the rest of the original anchor space. The newer small tenants, like Ready Up Gaming Lounge, Sports Unleashed, Crowned Studios, Higher Design Barber Studio and Grindhouse Tattoos, add to the mall's mix of services and things to do.
If a Galleria trip this season gets you wondering what the land under your own East York home is worth now that the mall next door is changing, Spencer Blake can run the numbers with you. Start with a free home valuation. I'll walk you through the recent sales near Whiteford Road and Springettsbury Park and give you a straight answer.