An updated York rowhouse kitchen with a white sink, warm neutral cabinetry and a sash window looking onto a small brick courtyard in late autumn.

York City's Property Tax Hasn't Moved Since 2018. The Sewer Bill Is Where the Cost Went.

Pennsylvania American Water's rate sheet for its York wastewater zone is only one page. The line that matters most is the charge for the first 2,000 gallons a household uses each month. Before August 13, 2026, that charge was $0.75 per 100 gallons. Starting August 13, it's $1.7345. The $15 monthly service charge stayed where it was.

If you're pricing a house or a duplex inside York City, that line belongs in your numbers next to the property tax. The city's real estate tax rate has been 18.97 mills since 2018. The sewer bill is what has been rising, and the two are tied together by a sale the city made in 2022.

The Bill Went Up Most for the Smallest Users

Here is Pennsylvania American Water's own comparison of residential bills in Zone 1b, the York zone, before and after August 13, 2026.

Gallons per month Prior monthly bill Bill from Aug. 13, 2026 Increase Percent change
1,000 $22.73 $32.35 $9.62 about 42%
2,000 $30.30 $49.69 $19.39 about 64%
3,000 $60.14 $83.89 $23.75 about 39%
4,000 $89.98 $118.09 $28.11 about 31%
6,000 $149.65 $186.49 $36.84 about 25%

The percentage column is my own math from the utility's figures. A household using 2,000 gallons a month took the biggest relative hit, because every one of those gallons falls in the tier that more than doubled. Above 2,000 gallons, the rate went from $2.9539 to $3.4199 per 100 gallons, a much smaller increase.

In a November 2025 filing in the rate case, the Office of Consumer Advocate's example York residential customer used 3,164 gallons a month and paid $65 under the rates in effect then. On the new rate sheet, that usage falls between the 3,000-gallon bill of $83.89 and the 3,500-gallon bill of $100.99.

This was also the second increase in about 15 months. The City of York reported that an earlier increase took effect May 27, 2025, raising the average bill by $36 a month. It was the first increase for city residents in eight years.

For an investor, the sewer bill matters in small multifamily.

Why Wastewater Rose More Than the Utility Asked

The statewide headline from the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission's July 16, 2026 decision pointed the other way. The PUC said it cut Pennsylvania American Water's original request by more than half. It approved $74.9 million in new annual revenue overall. Of that, $29.6 million went to wastewater, an increase of about 14.17%. The company had originally asked for a wastewater increase of a little over $16.1 million, about 7.7%.

The PUC order explains the gap. Pennsylvania's Act 11 lets part of the cost of wastewater service be charged to water customers. The company's proposal would have moved about $53 million of wastewater costs onto water bills. The Commission moved less than that, so more of the cost stayed on wastewater bills. The case is docket R-2025-3058051, and the new rates took effect August 13, 2026.

For a York sewer customer, that means a decision that lowered the overall request still raised the sewer bill. The PUC was deciding how to split costs between water and sewer customers, and this time more of the cost stayed with sewer customers.

What the Sewer Sale Bought the Tax Rate

Pennsylvania American Water closed on the city's wastewater system on May 27, 2022, and the York Dispatch reported the price as $235.3 million. The PUC had approved the deal unanimously on April 14 of that year. The terms held York City rates at their existing level for three years and required PUC approval for any later rate change.

The city has been clear about why it sold. In its 2025 notice about the rate increase, the city said that in 2020 residents faced a possible 48% tax increase and a 42% sewer fee increase. It said the sale money paid down city debt and the rest was invested, and that the investment income plus some of the principal had let residents go five years without a tax increase. In the same notice, then-Mayor Michael Helfrich called sewer fees "a more equitable cost to residents because they are based on everyone paying for the water they use and are paid by everyone, including our nonprofits that are not required to pay property taxes."

That is the trade in the city's own words. Part of the cost of running the city moved from a tax based on assessed value to a fee based on usage, and a fee based on usage also reaches properties that pay no property tax.

The 2026 budget shows how much depends on the sale money. According to the York Dispatch, City Council approved a $78.3 million general operating budget in December 2025 and balanced it with nearly $29.6 million from the wastewater treatment plant asset fund. The tax rate stayed at 18.97 mills, which works out to $948.50 in city tax on a property assessed at $50,000. The Dispatch also reported Helfrich's explanation for not using the proceeds to cut the rate: "If we reduce the taxes a tiny bit so that people will barely even feel that effect, we're actually going to be utilizing the principal and ... we lose any future dividends from that money." At that point he said about 80% of the proceeds remained.

The 2027 Budget Calls the Sale Money One-Time

Mayor Sandie Walker took office in January and presented the proposed 2027 budget at public hearings on October 21 and 22, 2026. At the opening of the October 21 hearing, she traced the city's budget gaps from a little over $6 million in 2016 to about $30 million in 2026. She said the 2026 budget used about $30 million in "one-time funding" from the plant proceeds to balance, and that "even though balanced budgets are here on paper that does not necessarily mean that we are a financially healthy city."

She also said federal ARPA money ends this year. Her administration has brought in the Pennsylvania Economy League to help with the 2027 budget and multi-year planning, and is reviewing staffing, vacancies, contracts and operating spending. In her words, the city "must also carefully manage our remaining one-time resources, which is the wastewater treatment plant funds." FOX43 reported her describing a multi-million-dollar deficit for 2027 and quoted her: "We don't want to put any burden on our residents."

At the same hearing, Walker said City Council has to adopt the 2027 budget before December 31, 2026. So the flat 18.97-mill rate has held this long because of a fund the current administration openly describes as one-time money. The council vote comes in the next six weeks.

A Bill Discount Program

There's also a bill program that's easy to miss. In its 2025 notice, the city said more than 5,000 city customers were eligible for Pennsylvania American Water's H2O Help to Others discount, but fewer than 450 had signed up. The PUC's July order requires the utility to put new screening and enrollment procedures for that program in place by November 11, 2026.

This is general information and not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm rates, lease terms and your own numbers with the right professional before you act.

Quick Answers

What does the tariff say about Springettsbury Township? Pennsylvania American Water's wastewater tariff lists Springettsbury Township as a bulk wastewater customer in the York zone, with its charges set by its own contract. The residential rates above are the ones the utility publishes for York customers.

Did the PUC give Pennsylvania American Water everything it asked for? No. Statewide, the Commission approved $74.9 million of new annual revenue and said it cut the original request by more than half. Wastewater was the exception, ending up at about 14.17% instead of the roughly 7.7% the company first requested.

Where can I check the rate myself? On Pennsylvania American Water's Zone 1b York rate sheet, which shows the prior rates, the rates effective August 13, 2026, and sample monthly bills from 500 to 8,000 gallons.

If you own a York City property or are looking at one, I can run its carrying costs with you. Start with a free valuation from Spencer Blake and we'll put the sewer line on the same sheet as the rent.

Let’s Find Your Dream Home

Real estate is personal, and so is my approach. As a York native with years of experience helping buyers, sellers, and investors, I create a tailored plan built around your goals. Whether you’re searching for your first home or your next investment, I’ll be by your side every step of the way.

Follow Me on Instagram